What Captain America: Civil War Must do to Distinguish itself

(While I’m writing this, Captain America: Civil War has debuted to mostly positive reviews in the U.K., but will debut in the U.S. later this week. So, if you’re reading this post from the U.K., I politely ask for no spoilers. But, if you are in the U.K., let us know briefly in the comments how you enjoyed or did not enjoy the movie!)

Superhero movies are the name of the game right now. I’ve made this point a handful of times on this blog before, and I don’t mean to belabor it, but comic book superheroes have gradually shifted from being a niche genre to cultural mainstays. Now, as with every genre, superhero films are starting to build upon genre conventions. The important thing to remember about genre conventions is to make sure they don’t become cliches.

The Avengers ends with a team of superheroes putting aside their differences before collaborating to take down a threat to humanity. Avengers: Age of Ultron ends with the same team welcoming people of questionable backgrounds, so that they can take down a threat to humanity. Guardians of the Galaxy ends with a team of superheroes putting aside their differences before collaborating to take down a threat to the galaxy. Batman v. Superman (SPOILER ALERT) ends with two superheroes realizing their mothers have the same first name  three superheroes putting aside their differences to take down a threat to humanity. Suicide Squad and Justice League will probably have similar endings. I assume you’re seeing a pattern here.

Cap Distinguish 2

My point is this; in order for Civil War to distinguish itself, there has to be a change in the formula. For the content of this movie to matter, to impact its fictional universe, the conflict between the two characters has to leave some residual scarring in the MCU. Things have to end with the fracturing of a friendship, instead of everything being resolved. In order for this movie to set itself apart, we must have two characters with irreconcilable differences, and no final villain that they have to fight after putting aside their disagreements.

Cap Distinguish 3

Batman v. Superman focused on two characters who had never met, but had a strong distrust of one another. And that’s fine, every cinematic universe has to start somewhere, I suppose. But Iron Man and Captain America have known each other for a few years, fought alongside each other, and, to be frank, they’ve seen some shit. And sure, they’ve disagreed on some matters, but there’s definitely still a bond between them.
. Sure, maybe the two friends are back together by the end of the film, but their friendship will feel some eventual scarring, and the world will no longer trust its heroes. Perhaps they can come back together later, in another film, but if they settled their differences by the end of this movie, the plot and their disagreements would have no true ramifications. This movie must capture the ethical/philosophical differences that Captain America and Iron Man have, while also showing the deterioration of their connection. In short, Civil War needs to work on a large scale and a small scale: it needs to show how bleak political and ideological battles can tear people apart and it needs to show the pain of losing a friend

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “What Captain America: Civil War Must do to Distinguish itself

    1. It had some high stakes, but it seems like it did not have quite a lasting effect. Sure, Steve/Bucky/T’Challa have their own separate team, and Rhodes is paralyzed, but by the time the epilogue rolled around, the fact that Steve offered Tony the chance to call him back whenever he needed made it feel as though not that much had happened.
      That being said, it’s difficult to know how this movie will effect subsequent ones. I suppose we’ll see the greater impact in those movies rather than what we have right now.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. True, feel like Civil War wasn’t really close to the comics, but that’s understandable considering the comics were far more involved and complex. And for one thing, I feel like marvel wanted to preserve the friendship between tony and Steven and also, maybe even more importantly they had to make sure the two were on non-murderous terms by the time infinity war will roll around. Plus, it did end with cap disregarding tony and breaking his friends out of prison 😄 I see what you’re saying though. Good work, keep it up

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s